Search This Blog

Tuesday, 13 July 2021

Dear Ally - "But it's just about respect"




~ Introduction ~

This began in response to a chat with my friend Anna, who remembered a conversation with her brother on trans rights. He died a few years ago, and she now wonders would he, out and proud gay man who suffered serious and sustained homophobic abuse as a teen, consider her a TERF? She is horribly unsure. 
She thinks he'd understand her, thinks he'd agree, but the way a particular school of thought has evolved, leaving many finding it inconceivable what she, we, think of as basic facets of reality, there's room for doubt.

Then I saw a woman expressing her exasperation with her husband, who dismisses her concerns over gender neutral changing rooms at work. He had asked her to post less on 'the gender stuff'. It was deeply condescending to his wife who has real concerns and reasons to come to the opinion she has.

Later, someone I know on Facebook 'corrected' me on a public post regarding Eddie Izzard. Underneath my comment, where I'd referred to Izzard as he, my friend simply wrote "*she*".

I explained that no, I wasn't doing this, I don’t want to play this game. And, I was told, it's all about respect.

That's normally the line - it's pretty simple, just use the pronouns. Make life easier for this marginalised group by not being a bigot. Just do it, no excuses, it isn't hard, and trans people go through so much more. Stop making your pedantic, miserly point at the expense of someone else's dignity. (I'm near certain I'll have said this to people myself in the past.)

Well, no, he didn't actually say the rest - he's a nice guy. I assume his position is based on a fundamental consideration for others - which I also have, and which is incredibly important to uphold. 
I just suggest it needs extending  little.
Things like knowing that trans people are often emotionally vulnerable makes it feel like it's only a little expression of courtesy that costs nothing; and, crucially, he's a socially conscious, left wing geezer who's probably stood up for many marginalised groups in the past, reads The Canary, Novara, follows Owen Jones etc, and thinks whatever he has heard about the debate over trans rights might not be comprehensive but it's probably pretty balanced.

But, knowing he is a nice guy, I wonder if he would be shocked if he saw it for what it is. 

Tuesday, 6 July 2021

WiSpa - #SRM - Breaching Boundaries

WiSpa

 #SRM - Breaching Boundaries: 

Update #2 charges filed against Darren Agee Merager - A man who identifies as a woman and has form for indecent exposure -
Merager is sought in an earlier incident

"This week, a warrant was issued in Los Angeles County for the arrest of 52-year-old Darren Merager, based on five felony counts of indecent exposure in connection with the Wi Spa incident. 

Everything about the Wi Spa was a bunch of garbage and lies,” Merager said in an interview. She says she is legally female in California"

"“She never saw me naked. I was underwater with water all the way up to my chest.” Merager denies ever being erect or around children at the spa. She says she is actually the victim of sexual harassment by transphobic women at the Wi Spa."

UPDATE #ConspiraWi Claims

[July 17th - Violent protests erupt again - article here]

Now this is being painted as a set up, a different set of arguments have emerged.

The reports of there being no transwoman at the spa at the time of the incident is being trotted out ad nauseam, but they could be identifying as simply a woman. 

Does it matter?

Well, obviously the truth matters, and while I don't believe for a moment this was staged (thus far another five women have come forward to say the same, some of the online reviews predate this by over a year, the spa released a statement at the time...) there is a way in which it's irrelevant. 
We know that the law in California allows this scenario, and we've also had two weeks of trans activists shouting that getting upset over the exposure is a hate crime; "don't look, bigot/pervert"

We are going to do another, more general piece on the glorification and justification of trans activists to breach boundaries and demands that women acquiesce as part of the #SRM - Sexual Rights Movement series. 

There are constant demands that come from the trans rights activist lobby, but as this incident at WiSpa has just emerged I thought I'd put all of this in one place.

The vilification of women who want / need single sex services is intense; we are prudes, uptight hags, ridiculous, hysterical pearl-clutchers. The idea of a little girl being in any way unsettled, frightened or traumatised by witnessing a naked man with a semi erect penis, who by the nature of his behaviour is clearly not dysphoric, is laughable to those who see any mention or reference to biological sex as harmful and likely to result in trans people's suicide.


These are the things they said would never happen. It's interesting to see the tactical retreat from denial that it could happen, to acceptance it has, with a new load of whataboutery and victim shaming instructions on not to look at the potential threat in front of you.

If a little girl can't go to a woman's spa, where other women are naked, without the danger of a bearded man waltzing in and sitting on the edge of the Jacuzzi she is in with his legs spread and his genitals at eye-level, then there is a problem.

I would also like to take this moment to condemn the right wing, MAGA-chanting men who also have tried to use this incident as a soapbox to shout from.

Let women speak. Listen to women. Stop telling women expressing their upset, concern, trauma and anger they are oppressive

Women hold far less power in this scenario, in most scenarios. This is evident from the 'anti fascist' bastards who saw this as an opportunity to unleash their violence and demands and the MAGA pricks. It's evident from the whole online conversation. Telling anyone to quell their instinctive responses to threats is abusive and an integral part of rape culture (beautifully explained here)

This occured in a Korean spa - specifically, a Jacuzzi. Among their group is an eight year old girl. A (purportedly) transwoman enters, completely naked, and the women become upset over the penis parading. A good video to cover the whole issue is this

Video here and thread:
 "The second, less viewed, part of the 'Wi Spa' footage. "His dick is swinging left and right. and it's the women's section.. he's an imposter." I'm not so keen on all the 'blood of Jesus' business but she makes a fair point" https://t.co/lCZE7GSImM

December 2022 - Merager does an incredible interview with lamag

And some responses: 

Katy Montgomerie is a haughty, dismissive prick (the shock!) ;

Mallorie Moore is most perturbed that the woman is religious. It's kind of a reverse Catholic shame thing:


Sally Hines;


Kirsty Slater aka Gemma Stone aka Not Cursed E



Alan Driscoll & David Paisley 



The author of this (read it here) has a colourful history of 'defending trans rights'...


An earlier incident:

The woman clearly did not record anyone except for the reception staff. The unremitting attempts to condemn and harangue her into submission as plain as day...


This is her video explaining

Another review of this spa (which is Korean, where the clients are often completely naked) -


"Upon checking in, the clerk advised us that "there was a transgender male in the women's locker room" ... Ok... No problem, I'm not the type to discriminate people, but once in the women's area, I saw the mentioned "transgender" individual naked in all his glory, and he still had a male organ hanging there...ok...no fuzz... That surgery is very expensive anyways, so I go on my routine and I get to the shower room, he was almost next to me showering too when I start to overhear hearing the conversation that he is having with a lady that was also in the shower area, I clearly heard him say that he has had sex with probably one hundred women and that he was looking for a female girlfriend to share his time with.... He also mentioned that he uses cocaine and LSD to "relax" .... I heard from other ladies there that he goes there quite often"

The woman in the original video is interviewed here, and appears to say that the transwoman had an erection.

Another response, after Toronto's sole women-only spa says it is, actually, women only...

Trans community speaks out against body blitz women only spa 
includes the excellent line 'penis-based policy';
"Rachael Kriss, a trans woman who works in IT and does corporate diversity training, left a critical comment on Body Blitz’s statement, along with a negative review, only to find both deleted. “It’s removing me, and my humanity. My existence has been erased,” She is concerned about Body Blitz’s penis-based policy because “it focuses on body parts, not gender.” These types of policies are dehumanizing"

And it's not just WiSpa...





















LibFem Responses: Laurie Penny, who thinks she's a feminist (and well, she looks all edgy in that profile picture) speaks the sort of 'truth' the mob power want and thus maintains her status as relevant, modern and 'intersectional';
 




Personally, I'd have thought biting back at a movement that insists there be no public area women and girls can be without the be-penised is quite important. Interesting that Penny's time is not wasted by this performative 'allyship' though;

<Not sure if this is just deliberately obtuse>


King Critical does a great job of debunking Penny here 


Does it ever occur to these people the reason the focus is on transwomen is because penises have been used as a weapon against women since time immemorial? The fact no one speaks of transmen is not only do they not endanger women's spaces or have a penis, they only breach the boundaries of men which is not the concern of feminism. I fully support men in guarding their own intimate spaces, gay saunas etc but this is not my fight. 









Over on Facebook, PinkNews and their readership of unparalleled idiocy get excited:

Typical PinkNews-sense


This horrifying comment right here goes entirely unchallenged except for the interjection of some 'TERFs'. It would appear this comment is from someone deliberately parodying the sentiment being expressed - and none of the pro-penile paraders complain








Karin speaks sense. Where is the solidarity and sympathy these supposed transwomen have with women?



Ah, here is a transwoman who shows some sisterhood. Predictably, she is attacked:

Holy trinity of rape culture! Time to blame the victim!








Thankfully, PinkNews soon found a spin:
What The Trans!? is some kind of organisation founded by self identifying woman and journalist Michelle Snow. Thank god Michelle asks the important, philosophical questions. Here's "what's the problem with penises exposed in supposed women's spaces?" Michelle:


In answer, TRuDOS speaks;

The brave new narrative - the terven want women to be sexually assaulted 



Definitely a hoax



No, you have no right to any penis-free space


Diane has helpfully revised Merager's history with the aid of multiple excuses

George here sounds like a great guy. And I'm sure trans liberation is his motive...



Buuut.... It's the TERFs who are violent!

Owen confirms what violent men have wondered since the primordial slime;




I think it's here we get to the crux of the matter; rejecting penises is what is really boiling the piss of these people;

 





The women organise a protest




And so Antifa (bourgeois flasher's chapter) stands with the notorious penis parader, and it erupts.
 (This has been tricky to compile, as so many of the initial videos posted have been removed - including entire twitter account of the woman detailing her experience with her 6 yr old daughter - article here)
These women have breached Facebook community standards for just sharing her video:

#ConspiraWi!

Now, did you notice a theme emerging in the comments there? Yes, that's right - it never happened. It's an anti-trans conspiracy theory! A false flag!

Here some YouTuber 'unpacks' the story into a series of magicians suitcases. Like 35 clowns into a mini, it's kind of impressive - although starting with the claim one of the 'transphobes' waded into a crowd of people with metal chains wrapped around his fists (sounds totally like a TERF, doesn't it?) and describing how you could hear these chains hit flesh, only to clarify actually it was a Catholic with rosaries is a little bit of a mess.







"The video quickly made the rounds in far right, and Trans-Exclusionary Feminist (TERF) sites and Anti-trans “feminist” websites."


Posie Parker talks to eye witness Belissa Cohen here



Andy Ngo covers antifa 'defending transwomen'

"Antifa mob attacked a woman protesting peacefully outside Wi Spa in Los Angeles. The spa was at the center of a recent viral video where a woman complained to staff that a person with a penis exposed their genitals to women & girls

You’re gonna get your ass knocked out

https://twitter.com/MrAndyNgo/status/1411389131033169921?s=19

https://twitter.com/MrAndyNgo/status/1411390644342312961?s=19


The woman seen having her hat and sign snatched is harassed as she tries to leave


The counter protest was organised by this lovely laddy, Precious Child (there are several people also claiming this is the flasher themselves, after PC said it could have been them. This is now refuted)





Here is where "PRECIOUS CHILD" insinuates he is the cock-flasher


Which then becomes a fundraiser and appeal to be recognised as the victim:





Mike makes some bold claims...



As do plenty more;




Angel, please tell me how to distinguish between a naked man and a naked pre-op, exhibitionist transwoman. I mean, sans clothing they won't even have a pronoun badge...

"Fighting & rioting broke out at the antifa counter-protest outside the Wi Spa in Los Angeles. Antifa gathered to assault those who opposed the spa over a purported incident where a person flashed their genitals to women & girls. Video by @TomasMorales_iv: https://t.co/vMt4GN3chb


Read Gaye's thread here



If they gave a definition of transphobe, it might make sense. But we know who they're actually talking about - those who don't want to interact with stranger's penises

The response generally is infuriating and tragic. Everywhere, women are told to ignore their instincts and boundaries.


Signs are taken from the women protesting and torn up


And continues 

It resembles fascism, funnily enough 

A couple at the protest, or simply walking through - it isn't clear - are harassed and shoved

This woman is abused and mobbed

"lets see how that went
And here is a large group of very vocal (mostly) men, bullying a woman protesting at the Wi Spa. They surround her, call her a bitch, snatch her sign & hat & steal her sunglasses



In response to this violence and forcibly evicting people using their right to protest, 'antifa' posted this

Which is great and everything, but I preferred this:





Now, during this brawl to assert authority over women, one man in full protective combat gear stabbed two people. Obviously, this is the fault of feminists. It's always a woman's fault. They must have been motivated by gender critical or radical feminists, there's no way men would act this way otherwise!


Id love to see the proof of this. The violence and threats levelled at feminists has ruined lives. I'm yet to see a single threat or attack against a trans activist (let's be clear, it's about the activists and not the people). The deliberate dishonesty is unforgivable.

The unparalleled Helen Steel talks here about just how screwed up it is. 
Helen was one of the two activists persecuted by McDonald's in the 'McLibel' trial. She is an incredible activist, who was also duped by an undercover police officer into a settled relationship until he one day disappeared off the face of the earth. 

After defending those handing out leaflets regarding the Gender Recognition Act reform proposals at the anarchist book fair in 2017, she was abused and assaulted (Helens words here, and an excellent summing up here). Since that time, despite her decades of activism, she has been abused as a TERF and ejected from protest camps. By eejits, who have never done anything as brave as she has, and have almost none of the critical analysis, political nous or integrity she has.

This is not about trans rights. 
These misogynistic thugs are not antifascist.

***

Some more tweets, as I find them:


@MsAnnaPhylaxis responded with The Rich Fantasy blog piece, as yet there has been no response





Another demo is planned;
Allison Bailey has a lemon and Wispa bar thrown into her garden. Only because of Allison's integrity does she explain later it was local kids who later apologised.

She didn't need to do that. The problem is, apart from the fact Allison has been harassed for years now, she has a dog. The dog ate some of the chocolate, and she had to seek veterinary advice. The right side of history swung in to mock her - including the big burly bloke David Paisley, who reported Marion Miller to the police for posting a picture of a ribbon in suffragette colours on some railings, because, to David, it somehow resembled a noose. He then fled his home in terror over unexplained fears of attack. 

Katy has made a career out of cultivating a reasonable, "I'll talk to anyone" persona. However this isn't  true. It's also quite rich having one of the heads of the pop-trans hydra accuse gender critical feminists of grifting...




 Remember notCursedE at the top? That's Gemma Stone - a freelance journalist who has been published in The Independent. 
Clearly upset by the accusations, Stone has a bit of a liberty considering their history (this is a tiny proportion)
Rozie Suppozie and the list of entitled demands drone on...